Name: Natalie
Comment: I’ve been dating a man for around a year, and there have been ups and down. But, we always find our way back to each other after a week or two of being ‘broken up’. This past Saturday, we were having a nice time out with each other. While he was in the restroom, I looked through his phone… I’m not sure why or what came over me. I know that this was a complete violation of his trust, which is kind of ironic, as that’s exactly why I’m upset with him now. I saw his dating profile, and looked at the sent messages to see that he messaged someone two weeks ago.
This was a time which I thought we were together and happy. Granted, we had had one of our ‘break ups’ a couple weeks prior. But, we were spending a lot of time together, sleeping together, and becoming very emotionally close again. I immediately let him know what I had done once he returned and what I had found. Of course, he became defensive and angry that I had gone through his phone (which is totally understandable).
SO, neither of us backed down. The night ended disastrously, and we have not really spoken since. I did invite him over last night (Sunday). Of course, he said he couldn’t.
Here are some things that are really bothering me about this:
1. He had told me that he wasn’t looking for anyone else, let alone messaging anyone. So, he lied about that.
2. We were, in my opinion, back together when he sent the message. He was willing to possibly create an entire new relationship when he’s telling me he loves me. So, I consider that cheating.
3. How am I supposed to trust that he hadn’t been doing this the entire time we’ve been dating? How am I supposed to trust that he won’t do it in the future?
Is he even worth my time to try to see his point of view? Am I overreacting to a message when he may have considered us broken up?
Thanks,
Natalie
Age: 30
City: Chandler
State: AZ
1. He had told me that he wasn’t looking for anyone else, let alone messaging anyone. So, he lied about that.
But…you said you had had one of your multiple breakups just a couple weeks ago. So how is this cheating? Yes, you are over-reacting to this.
2. We were, in my opinion, back together when he sent the message
Okay, but did he agree to that or even know that?
3. How am I supposed to trust that he hadn’t been doing this the entire time we’ve been dating?
Probably the same way he’s supposed to trust that you won’t wait for him to go take a shower so you can snoop through his phone. You’re just going to have to take it day by day. That’s all you can do.
I understand why you’re upset. You can feel however you like. Nobody gets to tell you what emotions to have in situations like these. They’re there, they’re yours, they’re all valid. Unfortunately they aren’t backed up by anything other than your assumptions.
Of course he lied about messaging other people. Most people in his situation would. If it’s between being honest and sparing yourself and another person pain, lying is often considered the kind or even humane thing to do. He’s allowed to want to feel cautious about getting back together again. He’s also allowed to keep his options open.
You can romanticize your relationship all you like by saying you have ups and downs and that you always find your way back to each other and all that rom com good stuff. That doesn’t make your relationship healthy or productive. You can’t just assume that, after each break up, things go right back to the way they were with all rules and expectations in place. It doesn’t work that way. You’re starting all over again in a sense. Every single time. You’re relationship wasn’t on pause during these splits.
Just because you believed you two were back together doesn’t make it so. Plus, you don’t get to be the only one who decides if you’re officially back together. Both of you have a say in that. I keep trying to get this point across: exclusivity is only real when it has been verbalized and agreed upon by both parties. And even then it’s just a promise not to screw up for now.
Is he even worth my time to try to see his point of view?
I..I don’t know. Did you think it was worth his time to see your point of view?
The problem I have with this is that this is just a series of one-sided rationalizations on your part. It’s all about you. You don’t appear to be considering his side at all.
Personally, I think it’s time to close the curtain on this relationship. There’s just too much water under the bridge and too many starts and stops for you two to be able to continue. You went looking for a problem and you found one, but you don’t have much context to use to determine whether any actual wrong doing occurred. That’s the typical outcome when someone snoops.










Follow/Friend Us